Coaching

Coach or therapist: which do I need?

They’re cousins, not twins. How to tell which one you need, and when the answer is both.

Noel RosencranzNovember 20, 20264 min read

It’s one of the first questions people ask before hiring a coach. Fair. Picking the wrong one is like seeing a dentist about a sprained ankle. They’ll be very nice about it. You’ll still be limping.

The short answer: coaching and therapy are cousins, not twins. They overlap, they get along at family gatherings, and they have very different jobs.

What therapy is for

Therapists are licensed health professionals. They diagnose and treat mental-health conditions: depression, anxiety, trauma, addiction, grief that won’t lift. They’re trained to work with what hurts, including where it came from. In the US, some of it may even be covered by insurance, which is more than coaching can say.

What coaching is for

Coaching isn’t mental-health treatment, and coaches aren’t licensed to provide it. In fact, nobody licenses coaches at all. In theory, a golden retriever could print business cards tomorrow. Some of them would be excellent listeners.

Coaching works on goals, decisions and behavior: where you want to go, what’s in the way, and the next step. Plus someone who asks, next week, whether you did it. Politely. Then a little less politely.

A good coach is not a cheaper therapist, the same way a personal trainer is not a cheaper orthopedic surgeon. Both care about your knees. Only one of them should operate.

Where they overlap

Both are conversations with someone paying close attention. Both involve good questions and honest answers. And a lot of what holds people back at work, like confidence, avoiding conflict, or being hard on yourself, shows up in both rooms.

So some people do both: therapy for the deeper work, coaching for the decision on Thursday. That isn’t overkill. You have a dentist and a mechanic, and nobody calls that excessive.

Probably a coach, if…

  • You’re basically okay, and you want something specific: a promotion, a business decision, a team that works better.
  • You know what you should do, and it isn’t happening.
  • You’ve read three books on productivity and are now very well read and exactly as productive.
  • The question is mostly “what next?” rather than “why does this keep happening?”

Probably a therapist, if…

  • Low mood, anxiety or stress has lasted weeks and gets in the way of daily life: sleep, eating, work, relationships.
  • Something from the past keeps showing up in the present, and you can’t shake it.
  • You’re using alcohol, food, work or anything else to get through the day.
  • You’re having thoughts of harming yourself. Please talk to someone today. In the US you can call or text 988, any time.

What a good coach does when it’s therapy

Says so. Out loud. A good coach knows where coaching ends, tells you when what you’re describing needs someone with a different license, and helps you find that person. If a coach treats everything as a mindset problem, find a different coach. Your mindset will thank you.

That’s how I work too. If therapy is what you need, I’ll tell you, even if it costs me a client. I’d rather lose a client than keep the wrong one.

Still not sure?

Try this: if it went well, what would be different in three months? If the answer is mostly about what you’d be doing (a decision made, a hard conversation had, a business moving), that’s coaching. If it’s mostly about how you’d feel, start with a therapist. If it’s both, congratulations, you’re a human being. Both is a fine answer.

Sources

Blind Spots is one idea like this, once a month. Get the next one 

Cousins, not twins.

If the coaching list sounded like you, the next step is a conversation. Thirty minutes, on me.

30 minutesZoom or phone